Press "Enter" to skip to content

No Progress Towards Peace After Moscow Talks, Analysts Say

(MOSCOW, RUSSIA) – Negotiations to end the war in Ukraine have intensified after a nine-month gap, but analysts say there is no evidence the talks have brought peace any closer or tamed Russia’s territorial demands.

US President Donald Trump’s envoys, Steve Witkoff and Jared Kushner, travelled to Moscow to brief the Russian dictator Vladimir Putin after what they described as productive talks with Russian and Ukrainian officials in Abu Dhabi.

The envoys are seeking to persuade Moscow to allow European representatives to join negotiations. Witkoff said he hoped a new round of talks involving Europe could be announced following the Moscow meeting.

Putin said he wants peace in Ukraine to last forever. Speaking after the meeting, he said foreign troops in Ukraine would be a legitimate target for Russian forces and threatened Russia’s national security, maintaining his opposition to European peacekeepers under any settlement.

Putin also said Russia would like the United States to work with Europe, and that Europeans should decide what they want: war or peace.

Steve Rosenberg, the BBC’s Russia editor, said Putin’s comments on territory indicated he still wants the entire Donbas. Putin said that for Russia there is only one demarcation line, namely the state border.

The territory question remains the central obstacle. Ukraine has refused to hand over parts of the Donbas that Russia has failed to capture in nearly five years of war, while Moscow demands the rest of the region.

Vitaly Shevchenko, chief analyst at BBC Monitoring, said nothing in the talks suggested peace was closer. He said Putin’s remarks fell within positions he has held for years, including rejection of foreign troops and insistence that Ukraine stay out of security alliances such as NATO.

Shevchenko said Putin’s talk of eternal peace amounted to peace on his terms.

He described Putin’s proposal for a localised ceasefire to evacuate the occupied city of Kostiantynivka as good news for those involved, but said it did not indicate broader cooperation. A similar arrangement was reached weeks earlier in Oleshky, further south in the Kherson region.

Shevchenko said Russian Deputy Foreign Minister Sergei Ryabkov’s remarks during the Abu Dhabi talks made clear Moscow still seeks to crush Ukraine.

He said Russia revived proposals for European security first floated in 2021, including demands that NATO withdraw from Eastern Europe, the Baltic states, the Balkans, Poland and the Czech Republic. He described the demands as unfulfillable and said they showed Russia would not compromise.

Kushner said the United States had begun discussing a new European security architecture with European allies.

Shevchenko questioned why a new framework was needed, given decades of arrangements between Europe, Russia and the Soviet Union that clearly implied Russia should not invade other countries.

He said European foreign policy chief Kaja Kallas had noted existing security arrangements were in place and that any review would benefit Russia.

Shevchenko said the US-led talks over almost two years had achieved little beyond emboldening Putin. He said the key measure of success was whether fewer people were dying, and that they were not.

He cited United Nations figures from September 2026 showing civilian casualties in Ukraine had risen by 85% over September 2025, according to BBC Monitoring.

Shevchenko said Russia and the United States had acted in ways that portrayed them as allies, with pressure concentrated on Kyiv. He said Europe had been Ukraine’s most steadfast supporter but was less wealthy and less militarily capable than the United States.

He said European participation at the negotiating table would relieve pressure on Ukrainian negotiators, but that words alone would not stop Putin. He said Putin needs to be given a reason to stop, and that all reasons offered so far had clearly failed.

Footage and analysis were released by BBC News in its Global News Podcast, with reporting from Moscow and analysis from BBC Monitoring, from Moscow, Moscow Oblast.

Be First to Comment

Leave a Reply