Press "Enter" to skip to content

Moscow Uses Euphemisms to Hide Maximalist Demands

(LONDON) – Russia’s demands for ending its war in Ukraine have not changed, though Moscow now tends to use broad euphemisms such as addressing the root causes of the war without spelling them out.

Mark Galeotti, executive director of Mayak Intelligence and honorary professor at the UCL School of Slavonic and East European Studies, said there are some things Russia absolutely wants.

They want the territories they have already captured, a guarantee that Ukraine will not become part of NATO, no NATO forces in Ukraine after any peace, and some kind of sanctions relief.

Everything else is in effect on the table, but the Russian approach is always to sound incredibly bullish and then make any concessions at the very last minute.

US envoys Jared Kushner and Steve Witkoff are in Moscow speaking to the Russian dictator Vladimir Putin.

A lot has been said about them being out of their league when it comes to negotiating an end to such a significant conflict.

The Kremlin is broadcasting the meeting with Kushner and Witkoff live, which suggests there is not much serious progress to be expected.

Galeotti said there are no rabbits about to be pulled out of hats and this is a fairly status quo kind of meeting.

The talks were never going to lead to some kind of sudden breakthrough.

He said he does not get the sense that the Russians have huge regard for Kushner and Witkoff, but they represent the United States, so it is the country behind them that really matters.

The very fact that the Russians are willing now to entertain the thought of Europeans coming into the peace process a little bit more, though under certain circumstances, suggests they also think the United States is a waning factor in this deal.

On the question of Europeans coming into negotiations, Kushner says he hopes to convince the Russian dictator to include Europeans.

Europeans have been saying they felt sidelined for years in these peace negotiations.

Moscow appears more focused this time around on drawing up a proposed European security framework.

Galeotti said Putin is talking about some kind of wider deal, not just a temporary ceasefire on Ukraine, but a proper deal that will settle the conflict once and for all.

He is trying to put the Ukraine conflict into a wider context and use this to push back.

It is not that he thinks any countries are going to be forced to leave NATO, but he wants to see less of what he calls NATO’s military architecture on Russia’s borders.

More to the point, he just wants that sense of being brought back into the European framework.

There is a great sense that Russia has been unfairly pushed out of a European family of nations to which it thinks it belongs.

So there is a mix of emotional and geopolitics coming in there, but he definitely wants to widen these discussions from just Ukraine.

On prospects for compromise, much of what is going on now is focusing on just one small territorial part of the Donbas region, the last bit, maybe around 18% to 20% of this contested Donetsk region.

Putin seems to think it is absolutely necessary for him to say he has liberated all of the Donbas, and therefore he is demanding that territory.

The Ukrainians can’t and won’t give it to him.

Galeotti said he does not think we can expect any kind of compromise certainly until spring because Putin will rely on the fact that he has a winter to hammer the Ukrainians, their power grid, their water supplies and so forth.

That said, there are a lot more positive noises from every side.

Zelenskyy said these negotiations had been serious and there was a window of opportunity.

So there is that sense that everyone is easing towards it, but for the moment the Donbas question is an intractable one and neither side looks willing or able to compromise on that.

On the efforts of the main mediator, the United States, the Trump administration has oscillated between supporting Ukraine and appearing to be closer to Russia.

Galeotti said Trump does seem to gravitate towards authoritarians of every stripe, in part precisely because as a dealmaker you have one person with whom you can make a deal rather than a whole democratic structure.

There is little evidence that Trump really cares about Ukraine one way or the other.

What he does care about seems to be the idea that he should win a Nobel Peace Prize.

If he wants some kind of final diplomatic triumph before the end of his increasingly short term period in office, then he has to move on this.

Trump will essentially align with whoever he thinks at any one time is the strongest partner in the conflict.

Most of the time he has been of the view that it was Russia. Sometimes he is convinced that it is Ukraine.

To be brutally honest, you can just toss a coin to decide on whose side Trump will seem to be on any given day.

On the credibility of peace processes, Galeotti said all peace processes are slow and painful.

What is different and what is the real problem with this particular process is just how public it is.

Usually peace processes are handled out of sight by experts and specialists, and then heads of state are only brought in right at the end to make the big announcement, sign the documents and generally take the credit.

In this, as in so many other aspects of Trump diplomacy, it has actually been turned around.

Trump makes grand declarations and various people try desperately to make it happen, and most of the time they don’t.

This is what we would expect from a peace process which is so intractable and where the situation on the ground frankly has not been changing all that much from month to month.

The problem has been just how public it is, and it may lose its credibility unfairly because Trump stoked so much expectation at the very beginning.

It is difficult to remember, at least in recent memory, a peace process that was indeed so public.

The interview was broadcast by FRANCE 24 English.

Be First to Comment

Leave a Reply