(KYIV) – A possible peace deal involving the Donbas in exchange for Ukraine’s NATO membership is raising fundamental questions about Ukraine’s future and Europe’s security, according to analysts.
The proposal, which is not a Russian one but an American one, would reportedly see Ukraine cede territory it still controls in the Donbas in exchange for NATO membership.
Marcin Zaborowski, Europe Editor at TVP World, said the idea is not coming from the Russian dictator Vladimir Putin.
“It’s coming from one of the US envoys,” he said. “So that means either Mr Kushner or Mr Witkoff. It must have been one of them who communicated it to President Zelensky.”
Zaborowski noted that President Zelensky decided to make the proposal public to gauge reaction.
“It must have been some kind of a reason for President Zelensky to do that because it sounds like that it was just a conversation in the lobby,” he said. “What would you do if we were to offer you NATO membership? Would you be willing to accept Russian demand for Donbas?”
The proposal has been met with scepticism from European leaders.
Kaja Kallas, the EU’s foreign policy chief, said: “They started the war. They are the aggressor and there’s one victim. We need to seek concessions from their side so that we would have a just and lasting peace in Ukraine and also in Europe.”
Zaborowski said the reality on the ground is that Russia controls most of the Donbas, but its advance has stalled.
“Russia would like to have the entire Donbas,” he said. “So Ukraine would need to cede the rights not only to what it already lost control over but also further territory that it still controls.”
He added: “It seems very unfair and very unjust. But maybe there’s a way to stop the war.”
However, he cautioned that it is too early to say whether the proposal is genuine or merely probing.
“Would Ukraine become a NATO member state immediately? Or would there be just a promise of NATO membership? All these big questions are still hanging up in the air,” he said.
Zaborowski noted that many nations throughout history have given up considerable parts of their territories in exchange for peace and security.
He cited the example of Ireland, which accepted a peace deal in 1920 or 1921 that recognised Britain’s control of Northern Ireland as a temporary solution. That arrangement remains in place to this day, though the Republic of Ireland continues to hold a legal claim to the entire island.
The question of Crimea also remains unresolved.
“I don’t think that realistically we are talking at all about Ukraine ever, or at least not in the immediate future, and I don’t think that probably ever legally accepting that any part of the pre-2014 territory is legally becoming Russia’s,” Zaborowski said.
“But that’s one thing to actually legally cede a part of territory. There is another thing to actually recognise a status quo.”
He said Ukraine has already indicated it would be prepared to accept peace on the condition of a permanent ceasefire along the current lines.
“This is not saying that Donbas is becoming part of Russia and that Ukraine is recognising it,” he said. “Ukraine is just simply recognising the status quo as it is, just as Germany did in the 1950s.”
The proposal has also raised concerns about Europe being left out of discussions.
German Foreign Minister Johann Wadephul said: “Europe has a security architecture and we do not need a new one. All we need is for everyone to respect the existing security architecture. From the European perspective, that is the basis for any conceivable agreement. We will hold this course, however loudly others protest.”
Zaborowski said the conversation is still in the probing stage.
“It’s not a serious proposal at the negotiating table right now,” he said. “It’s too early. Europe will be involved in the part of the serious talks and this country will be involved in parts of the real talks about the future of Ukraine.”
He noted that President Zelensky has said he is open to very serious discussion about territorial issues in the format of direct talks with Russia, with the United States and perhaps with Europe also at the table.
“It requires conversation between top leaders, not technical talks,” Zaborowski said.
The Russian dictator Vladimir Putin has made maximalist demands in recent days, including that Finland leave NATO and that NATO pull out from the territory of the Baltic states.
He has also made demands regarding Moldova, including that it federalise itself.
“These are basically demands concerning our sovereignty, the sovereignty of the Baltic states,” Zaborowski said. “There has not been an explicit demand on Poland, but I think it’s only a matter of time.”
He added: “Putin knows very well that this is ridiculous and nobody’s going to accept that. But he can keep saying that, ‘Well, I’m ready to talk. I’m a good guy around here.’ And in the meantime, he continues to bomb Ukraine into submission.”
Zaborowski said Putin is playing for time.
“He knows that these proposals are absolutely unacceptable,” he said. “I cannot believe that he would ever accept Ukraine joining NATO. He does not believe that Ukraine is anything different from Russia.”
However, Zaborowski noted that if NATO membership is agreed and Article 5 applies to the entire territory of Ukraine, then Putin would be at war with NATO if he continued his aggression.
“Then it’s not much that Putin can do about it really,” he said. “Because then going to war with Ukraine, continue to be at war with Ukraine means that Putin is at war with NATO and NATO would need to react or it would be the end of the alliance.”
On what could stop Putin, Zaborowski said the only thing is trouble at home and Russian public opinion turning against the war.
“Russia has been quite skillful in diversifying away from Europe, finding other alternatives to the delivery of its crude materials in Asia and India,” he said. “For now, if you are a Russian middle class member working for a Russian or international corporation, you don’t really feel war that much.”
He added: “We need to get in a situation in which the Russians would truly feel that they disrupted somehow, and it’s beginning to happen that way because of the Ukrainian hits at the Russian refineries, also Ukraine paralysing the movements of civilian air traffic movements.”
Zaborowski said that as long as Ukraine has the capacity to hit targets in Russia, the Russian people will start to feel the consequences of the war.

Be First to Comment