(DONETSK OBLAST, UKRAINE) – The Russian military is advancing at such a slow pace that, according to its own data, it would take approximately 31 years to capture the remaining 10% of Donetsk Oblast still under Ukrainian control.
The calculation is based on Russian military blogger Creamy Caprice’s assessment that Russian forces advanced at a rate of 0.24 square kilometres per day in October. That is a quarter of a kilometre per day across the entire front line, not in one sector.
According to Ukrainian sources and mappers who publish all their geolocation data, Russia may have actually lost territory in October.
Even accepting the Russian figure of 0.24 square kilometres per day, and General Valery Gerasimov’s statement on 16th October that Ukraine still holds approximately 2,748 square kilometres in Donetsk, the math points to decades rather than months.
The situation has become so embarrassing for the Kremlin that Russian military correspondent Vladimir Romanov, one of the few reporters willing to push back on official claims, may have been detained in Sevastopol. He faces potential criminal charges for publishing what Russia calls fake materials about the humanitarian operation in the Kherson area.
Romanov had reported that 17 buses of people were taken to Ukraine and that the majority of the population preferred to evacuate there. Both Russian and Ukrainian sides later stated that the number of buses could not determine the number of displaced people, as some buses had been reserved in advance.
Romanov had also called out General Gerasimov specifically, saying the report from the chief of the general staff to the Russian dictator Vladimir Putin contained information that was partially or completely inaccurate.
He said: “Lyman is not under our control. Both our forces and the enemy forces are there. The distance to the most forward position in Zaporizhzhia is 23 kilometres. Enemy forces are still present in Kupiansk.”
He added that the western group under Gerasimov’s patronage once again reported inaccurate information to Putin, saying that entering a settlement with three soldiers and waving a flag for broadcast, followed by enemy counterattacks, does not constitute capturing the settlement.
Romanov said there are grounds to believe that Russia will soon see “the view from the other side” from many of the settlements marked on the map, meaning Ukraine will publish footage showing it still controls areas Russia claims to have captured.
On the Dnipropetrovsk front, Russian media outlet Rybar has acknowledged deteriorating conditions. It said: “Cold weather is approaching, and it is a double-edged sword. Yes, it will become harder for the enemy to operate in small groups in the fields, but Russian units in the grey zone will not have it easier either.”
Rybar noted fresh reports of deteriorating conditions and consolidation of Ukrainian formations from the Dnipropetrovsk direction. Since February, Ukraine has achieved results by gradually occupying previously emerged gaps in the extensive grey zone along the border with Dnipropetrovsk.
The Russian blogger was tipped off by footage of a Ukrainian resupply drone moving forward before being struck by a Russian FPV drone. Russian sources questioned how a Ukrainian unmanned ground vehicle was operating in territory they claimed to control, when in reality it was not controlled by Russia at all.
This is just another case of Russian exaggerations genuinely costing Russian lives on a daily basis. There are occasion after occasion where Russian forces believe they are moving through occupied territory when in reality it is a grey zone filled with Ukrainian drones, and they are marching into a death trap.
It is important to note that these are not massive changes of territorial control. The changes are tens or hundreds of metres at a time, perhaps a few square kilometres over the course of larger counterattacks.
Ukraine’s major operation Vivaldi, for example, was a significant achievement but appears as a tiny sliver on the map when zoomed out. This does not downplay what Ukrainian soldiers accomplished, but it illustrates the nature of the conflict.
Ukraine is not attempting to recapture all territory taken by Russia. Its goal is to stop Russia from advancing, and it is doing that effectively. At times this requires counteroffensive operations like Vivaldi, which was not about liberating territory, although that was a byproduct, but about stopping the Russian advance into the fortress belt.
Ukraine has made it increasingly deadly for Russian forces to advance, with Russia gaining less by the day while losing more people and equipment.
The approaching winter favours Ukraine. As trees lose their leaves and vegetation disappears, Russian soldiers will have nowhere to hide in tree lines. Being exposed in freezing weather in no man’s land for days or weeks is a death sentence.
According to the Institute for the Study of War, Russia is suffering increasing casualties for effectively no gains on the battlefield.
The crackdown on Russian military bloggers who report accurately is a significant development. Romanov had raised large sums of money and equipment for the Russian military, with a focus on medics, and regularly put himself at risk near the front line.
It did not matter. Russian authorities came after him anyway.

Be First to Comment