Press "Enter" to skip to content

Ukraine says US proposed exchanging Donbas for NATO membership

(KYIV, UKRAINE) – Ukraine has disclosed that US representatives proposed a possible arrangement under which Kyiv would surrender the eastern Donbas region to Russia in exchange for NATO membership, raising questions about Washington’s approach to ending the war and the future of European security.

Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelenskyy said the proposal was raised by US envoys Steve Witkoff and Jared Kushner during discussions on ending Russia’s war against Ukraine. The two representatives had met Russian dictator Vladimir Putin in Moscow before holding talks with Zelenskyy in Dublin.

Donbas, which comprises the Donetsk and Luhansk regions, has been the scene of some of the fiercest fighting since Russia began its military aggression against Ukraine. Russian forces currently control most of the territory, alongside other occupied areas.

Ukraine has consistently rejected surrendering its sovereign territory as part of a peace settlement. However, Zelenskyy has indicated that Kyiv could consider discussing the proposal if it included credible security guarantees, maintained Ukraine’s military capabilities and provided substantial support for post-war reconstruction.

Zelenskyy said he would put such an arrangement before Ukrainian society if the United States formally confirmed the proposal alongside other NATO partners.

“Think, if the American side confirms precisely this to us together with other NATO partners, then I will ask our Ukrainian society what it thinks. Do we accept it or not?” he said.

His remarks suggest that Ukraine has not formally accepted the proposal and that any decision involving territorial concessions would require consideration by the Ukrainian people.

DW correspondent Nick Connolly, reporting from Kyiv, said Zelenskyy’s decision to make the proposal public appeared intended to demonstrate how far discussions had moved from the practical realities of the war.

Connolly said the Trump administration had repeatedly indicated that it was not prepared to offer Ukraine NATO membership in the immediate future, making the suggested exchange difficult to reconcile with Washington’s existing position.

He described the discussions involving Witkoff and Kushner as an attempt to explore unconventional proposals, but said the idea appeared distant from political and diplomatic realities.

According to Connolly, Zelenskyy’s decision to refer the question to Ukrainian society was also a way of making clear that he would not personally assume responsibility for accepting such an arrangement.

He said the Ukrainian president would face considerable domestic opposition if he agreed to surrender territory after years of fighting, particularly from Ukrainian soldiers and families who had suffered during the war.

The proposal has emerged amid continued pressure on Ukraine, including restrictions imposed by the United States on Ukrainian access to Starlink services and Russian attacks against the country’s energy infrastructure.

Connolly reported that parts of central Kyiv were experiencing darkness during his broadcast, illustrating the continuing impact of Russian attacks on civilian infrastructure.

Meanwhile, there has been little indication that Moscow is prepared to moderate its demands.

Witkoff and Kushner met Putin in Moscow on Thursday, but the discussions have not produced clear evidence of a change in Russia’s position on ending the war.

Connolly said the Kremlin appeared to be expanding its demands rather than moving towards a ceasefire.

Ukraine and several European countries have maintained that a ceasefire should first be established along the existing front lines, with wider discussions about Europe’s security arrangements taking place afterwards.

Russia, however, has previously insisted that a broader post-war settlement addressing its demands must be agreed before it would accept a ceasefire.

Moscow’s demands now appear to extend beyond Ukraine, including proposals to reverse NATO’s expansion since the mid-1990s, withdraw American and other NATO forces from Eastern and Central Europe, and restrict the ability of European countries to benefit from the alliance’s nuclear deterrence arrangements.

Russia has also sought to create conditions in which individual European countries would have to negotiate separate non-aggression agreements with Moscow.

Connolly said such demands were unrealistic and unlikely to be accepted by NATO members, including Finland and other countries that joined the alliance in recent years.

He argued that Moscow’s approach suggested it was participating in diplomatic discussions without a genuine willingness to reach an agreement.

Instead, Russia appeared to be making demands so extensive that negotiations would become increasingly difficult to conclude.

Despite the limited prospects for a comprehensive settlement, smaller humanitarian agreements remain possible.

Connolly pointed to discussions following a previous meeting in Abu Dhabi, where Kushner announced what he described as the largest prisoner exchange.

He said such an exchange would be welcome and represented an area where limited cooperation between the parties could produce practical results.

Another example was the evacuation of civilians from Oleshky in the occupied Kherson region. Connolly said US First Lady Melania Trump had been able to present the operation as a diplomatic achievement and had received a medal from Zelenskyy in recognition of her involvement.

He suggested that similar localised humanitarian arrangements could continue even if a broader peace agreement remained out of reach.

However, Connolly said Putin appeared to be maintaining the same fundamental demands he had made in late 2021, before launching the full scale invasion of Ukraine.

He added that the Russian dictator did not appear to be under sufficient pressure to end the war.

Connolly also referred to a cyberattack against Russia’s state statistics agency, Rosstat, and figures cited from Russian official information which, according to his account, indicated that more than 400,000 Russian soldiers had been killed, with additional personnel missing in action.

Despite these reported losses, Putin appeared determined to continue the war rather than accept a settlement that did not involve substantial Ukrainian concessions.

Michael Kimmage, an expert on US Russian relations and director of the Kennan Institute in Washington DC, described the proposed exchange of Donbas for NATO membership as “science fiction”.

He said NATO was not designed to accommodate such an improvised arrangement and that, as far as he knew, there had been no consensus building among alliance members on the proposal.

Kimmage also pointed to Russia’s demands that NATO return to what Moscow describes as its 1997 configuration and that Finland be removed from the alliance.

He said these demands made the proposed arrangement particularly difficult to implement.

Although the proposal had been raised, Kimmage said there was little indication that it could be translated into a workable agreement.

He added that Russia’s opposition to Ukrainian NATO membership was only one obstacle.

Several NATO members had expressed reservations about Ukraine’s membership prospects since the 2008 Bucharest summit, when the alliance declared that Ukraine would eventually become a member.

Kimmage cited Germany, Turkey and other European countries, as well as the possibility of opposition in the US Senate, which would have to approve the arrangement.

He argued that the obstacles to Ukrainian NATO membership were therefore present not only in Moscow but also in Western capitals.

On possible alternatives, Kimmage said Ukraine would probably seek security guarantees resembling Article 5 of the NATO treaty, which establishes the principle of collective defence and requires alliance members to assist a member that comes under attack.

However, he questioned whether Ukraine would ultimately receive a guarantee equivalent to NATO membership.

Instead, he suggested that closer military and defence industrial cooperation with Western countries could become the most realistic option.

Germany and Ukraine have expanded their defence industrial cooperation over the past four years, while the United States and Ukraine have also developed their partnership, including during Trump’s administration.

Kimmage said further cooperation could strengthen Ukraine’s security, although it would not provide the same protection as a formal security guarantee.

He argued that diplomatic agreements and formal alliances might remain difficult to secure, but practical defence cooperation was achievable.

The discussion also examined the possibility of a meeting involving Putin, US President Donald Trump and Chinese President Xi Jinping.

Kimmage referred to an opinion article he had written for The New York Times, titled Trump Is Still Chasing His Yalta. Here’s What He Doesn’t Get.

He said the central problem with attempts by major powers to negotiate arrangements affecting smaller countries was that the international circumstances of 2026 were fundamentally different from those of 1945.

At the Yalta Conference in February 1945, Europe was devastated by the Second World War, while American and Soviet armies occupied large parts of the continent.

Kimmage said those circumstances had allowed Washington and Moscow to exercise considerable influence over Europe’s political future.

He argued that the situation was now entirely different.

The United States was, in several respects, reducing its military presence in Europe, while Russia remained trapped in a war it had been unable to win decisively and was making only limited territorial advances in eastern Ukraine.

Consequently, neither Washington nor Moscow possessed the power to redraw Europe’s political map in the way the major powers had done towards the end of the Second World War.

Kimmage said the balance of international power had changed considerably, making attempts to impose a new settlement on Europe without the involvement of European countries increasingly unrealistic.

He also questioned whether Ukraine would feature prominently in the proposed meeting between Trump, Putin and Xi Jinping.

One of the main challenges would be securing agreement among the three countries to discuss Ukraine, given the complexity of their competing interests.

He said arms control and nuclear non-proliferation were potentially more realistic subjects for discussion, as the United States, Russia and China are the world’s major nuclear powers.

The three countries could therefore have an interest in discussing the future of nuclear weapons and international arms control arrangements.

However, Kimmage said any meaningful discussion about Europe’s security or Ukraine’s future without European participation would be difficult to justify.

He concluded that although Ukraine might feature in the discussions, he did not expect the proposed summit to produce significant diplomatic breakthroughs.

Be First to Comment

Leave a Reply