Press "Enter" to skip to content

US Deporting Russian Asylum Seekers Back to Face FSB, BBC Investigation Finds

(WASHINGTON, DC) – The United States is deporting Russian asylum seekers back to Russia, where they face interrogation by the FSB security service, arrest, and imprisonment, according to a BBC investigation.

The number of Russians removed from the US rose from 222 in 2023 to more than 1,200 in 2025.

One of those deported was a woman the BBC is calling Katya, an opposition activist who fled Russia after the full scale invasion of Ukraine.

On a special flight organised by the US government that landed at Moscow’s Domodedovo airport in December last year, her knees were shaking with fear. She said it was unbelievably frightening.

She thought that after being interrogated, they would arrest her formally, open a criminal case against her, and simply lock her up.

When she got off the plane, she was greeted by a long line of FSB officers.

They questioned her for about two hours, mocked her, and asked personal questions about her life, why she left Russia, why she went to the US, and about her political activity.

At one point, they found incriminating information on her phone. Their faces changed in a second, but they released her.

After she returned home, the police came and questioned her again. Because of the nervous stress, her hair started falling out.

Whenever she sees a police car, she feels terrified and thinks: “What if they’re coming for me?”

She is certain her mobile phone is being monitored. She lives in fear in her hometown, but she is still in Russia, which is why the BBC has protected her identity.

Since Russia launched its invasion of Ukraine in 2022, thousands of Russians have fled the country, many hoping the West would offer them protection.

Many are now finding themselves sent back, potentially into the hands of the very authorities they were trying to flee.

Under President Joe Biden, there was a relatively liberal immigration policy in the US. When Donald Trump returned to the White House, he launched a wide ranging crackdown on immigration, meaning thousands of Russians were suddenly at risk of deportation.

The US Department of Homeland Security said all illegal aliens receive due process. If a judge finds an illegal alien has no right to be in the country, they said, they will remove them.

There is no evidence to suggest there is some sort of deal between Moscow and Washington to return these people to Russia.

One theory is that the US government ensures these people are sent all the way back to Russia to create a deterrent, so that others understand they will be deported back to the FSB and into serious peril.

One case that has shocked observers is that of Artium Vorvchenka, a Russian soldier from a small town in southern Russia who was conscripted in 2019.

In 2021, before the full scale invasion, he says he was tricked into signing a contract to become a professional soldier. When the invasion happened in 2022, he was opposed to the war and made it clear.

His senior officers pressured him and planned to deploy him to Ukraine. For Artium, this was completely beyond the pale. He was opposed to killing Ukrainians.

Just before his deployment, he was allowed a brief period of leave to see his family. During that leave, he took transport out of Russia, made his way to Mexico, and crossed the US southern border.

He provided evidence to the US authorities that he had been a Russian soldier, that they tried to deploy him to the war in Ukraine, that he had refused, and that a criminal investigation had been opened against him for desertion.

Despite that, US authorities rejected his request and deported him.

When he arrived in Moscow, he was taken into interrogation. As soon as the FSB realised he was wanted, he was detained and handed over to the military police.

He was taken to a military police detention facility near Moscow. Faced with the prospect of being handed back to the Russian security services, he was prepared to die. He said his only thought was how he could die without any pain.

He later spotted an opportunity to escape in the confusion of being transported between the detention facility and a health clinic. He got a taxi to a town and from there managed to reach Belarus, which has no hard border with Russia.

He booked himself a flight to another country outside the region and spent a very nerve wracking few minutes crossing the border, having his passport checked by Belarusian border guards. He expected any minute that one of those border guards would sound the alarm and arrest him. It did not happen.

He is now in another country outside Russia. The BBC has not said where for his own safety.

He is angry at his treatment in the US. He says he should have been allowed to leave freely and apply for asylum in another country that would have investigated his case properly, instead of being violently bundled back onto the flight to Russia.

Another case is that of Leonid Milkin, an anti war activist who posted photographs of the Russian dictator Vladimir Putin on social media with the message: “Putin murderer, fascist usurper.”

After he was deported, he was arrested at the airport and charged with justifying terrorism. Just a couple of weeks ago, he was sentenced to six years in a prison colony.

Katya said that every single male deportee on her flight was given summonses, military papers.

The BBC also found that several EU countries, including Germany and Finland, have seen a significant rise in the number of Russians they are deporting.

The reason is similar to the US. In Europe in recent years, there has been a huge surge in support for right wing populist parties, and a lot of that support is related to immigration.

As a result, countries like Germany have taken a much tougher line against migrants, and Russian asylum seekers are being swept up in that crackdown.

Chancellor Mets has said he understands the concerns of ordinary Germans about the high numbers of migrants allowed into the country and will take a tougher line.

One campaigner, Andre Pivar, part of the exiled anti war committee, a collection of Russian politicians in exile who oppose the war, said they have changed their advice to dissidents. They say: “Do not go to the EU. It is no longer safe.”

The recruitment situation in Russia itself is only going to get worse. There have been rumours of a general mobilisation, which the Russian dictator denied in September, calling it complete nonsense and an information attack on Russia.

If such a mobilisation did happen, there would almost certainly be a huge new wave of departures, larger than the one in September 2022 when hundreds of thousands of Russians left.

One organisation, ARC, which helps Russians trying to flee the country including deserters from the army, said that in August they had 10 times as many requests for help as just a few months before.

When Russians hear stories like those of Artium and Katya, they feel incredibly disillusioned by the West. Many have felt disappointed by the West’s approach to Russia for many years.

Now, with repression in Russia intensifying at an incredibly alarming rate and rising numbers of Russians being deported back, they see what they regard as a refusal from Western countries to help ordinary Russians who are opposed to the Kremlin.

They feel betrayed by Western countries.

The investigation was published by BBC News.

Be First to Comment

Leave a Reply