Press "Enter" to skip to content

Lavrov Mocks Europe as Talks Begin in Abu Dhabi

(ABU DHABI) – The first face to face talks between Russia and Ukraine in more than nine months have concluded in Abu Dhabi, with analysts sceptical that Moscow is genuinely seeking peace.

The talks, mediated by Jared Kushner, US President Donald Trump’s son in law, and his business partner Steve Witkoff, brought Russian and Ukrainian negotiators to the same table. The presidents themselves were absent.

The previous round of talks in Geneva failed to yield long term results. Washington said the aim was not only to discuss bilateral issues and humanitarian relief but also to create new security relationships between Ukraine, Russia and Europe.

The talks began just hours after fresh Russian attacks on Ukraine. Moscow’s invasion has killed hundreds of thousands. As another winter of war approaches, Ukraine and its European allies fear Washington will force Kyiv to accept a de facto defeat.

Kyiv’s delegation, headed by intelligence chief Rustem Umerov, reiterated its hopes for an end to fighting as soon as possible. “Our people are waiting to end this war and we hope that we will achieve a lasting peace,” Umerov said.

Russia’s delegation did not call for an end to fighting, merely for steps to be taken in that direction. “We hope that today’s meeting will enable us to make progress towards peace in the interest of the people of Russia and the people of Ukraine,” the Russian delegation said.

The Russian dictator Vladimir Putin has insisted that Ukraine surrender the entire eastern region of Donbas before a peace deal can be struck, something Ukraine’s President Volodymyr Zelenskyy has refused to countenance. Unless one side is willing to cede significant territory, such rounds may prove pointless.

Discussions continue on Wednesday, with the possibility that Zelenskyy and Putin may meet face to face before the end of the year.

DW correspondent Juri Rescheto, reporting from Riga, said it is easier to say what Putin does not want to achieve, which is a quick peace deal. Russia says it wants to discuss Europe’s security architecture yet does not want Europeans at the table.

Hours before the talks, Russian Foreign Minister Sergei Lavrov mocked European leaders in Abu Dhabi, saying “let them stay in their hotel”. Rescheto said this suggests Putin is using the talks less to build a new security order and more to test the Americans and see how far Washington is willing to go and how much pressure it might put on Europe.

Putin’s main goals appear unchanged: Ukraine gives up the occupied territories in the east, especially the Donbas, and drops its NATO ambitions. The bigger concern in the Baltic states is that Putin may be thinking beyond Ukraine when he talks about Europe’s security.

Asked why Putin will not agree to stop fighting while negotiations continue, Rescheto said the Russian dictator argues a ceasefire would only help Ukraine regroup, rearm and return stronger. The real reason, he said, is that Putin still believes he can improve his position on the battlefield. Every bit of territory Russia captures strengthens his hand in future negotiations.

Rescheto said Putin does not really have to convince Russians of anything. The Kremlin has been cautious about the talks from the start and Russian state media is presenting them the same way. Expectations are low and the Kremlin may be using the talks to buy time rather than reach a breakthrough.

The basic problem remains unchanged: Putin wants the Donbas, Zelenskyy will not give it up. The only area where progress seems possible is prisoner exchanges.

On Kushner’s suggestion that Russia might allow Europeans to join the talks, Rescheto said Putin wants a deal but on his terms. His key demands are no NATO membership for Ukraine and Russian control over the entire Donbas. Other demands may still come.

Ian Bond, deputy director of the Centre for European Reform and former British ambassador to Latvia, described the talks as “a bit of theatre”. He said the Russians are not really interested in peace and the Americans are not really interested in negotiating peace. They are interested in business deals and putting pressure on the Ukrainians and Europeans to concede to Russia.

Bond said he does not believe the talks will go anywhere. He is not concerned that they represent the beginning of Russia crafting a completely new security architecture for Europe, because that cannot happen as long as Europeans are not at the table and do not agree to it.

He acknowledged it is possible the US could agree to withdraw troops from Europe and leave NATO, but said even Trump may have second thoughts and the outgoing Republican majority Congress would probably try to stop him. He described the talks as “essentially pretty empty” like previous rounds.

Before invading Ukraine, Russia demanded that NATO roll back its military presence in Eastern Europe. Bond, who was Britain’s ambassador to Latvia, said if anyone was stupid enough to agree to such terms, Europe would become much less secure.

He described Putin as a man who believes he is gathering the Slavic lands, which he regards as extending well beyond Russia’s current territory and even beyond what he occupies in Ukraine. For the Baltic states, Poland and Finland, this would mean greater military pressure from the east. But Bond said he does not think even the Trump administration would be foolish enough to give Putin what he wants in this area.

European officials are in Abu Dhabi but Russia refuses to negotiate directly with them. Bond said Russia cannot dictate the future of Europe. It has been bogged down in eastern Ukraine for most of the last five years. It can do damage and be disruptive, but it is not in a position to dictate terms to the rest of Europe.

Bond argued that Europe needs to resist and constrain Russia even without reliable American support. Europe is a continent of 500 million people with a GDP many times that of Russia. It needs to decide that defending itself is a priority. Political will, not practical capacity, is the problem.

He noted that German Chancellor Friedrich Merz has been doing a good job of building up Germany’s armed forces, as have the Polish government and the Nordic Baltic region. Others, including the UK, have barely started and need to step up.

“We shouldn’t keep telling ourselves how weak we are,” Bond said. “Russia is a lot weaker than we are. It is just more prepared to use violence than we are.”

Be First to Comment

Leave a Reply