Press "Enter" to skip to content

Edward Lucas: Crimea Is Putin’s Weak Point

(LONDON) – Ukraine’s strikes on the Kerch Bridge have turned Crimea from a Russian trophy into a hostage, with supply lines to the peninsula now so constrained that life there is becoming unsustainable, according to Russia expert Edward Lucas.

Lucas, founder of the Baltic International Security Centre and a writer on European and transatlantic security, told Frontline that Russia cannot bring supplies to Crimea by sea because Ukrainian drones can sink any ship, and cannot use the bridge because it has been struck. That leaves only the overland route through occupied southeastern Ukraine, which is under almost 100% Ukrainian fire control.

“There’s difficulties with food and fuel and just keeping everyday life supplied,” Lucas said. “Crimea is rather like Kaliningrad in that it’s meant to be a trophy and it’s turning into a hostage.”

He said the Russian dictator Vladimir Putin’s grip on Crimea becoming unsustainable is “probably one of the best ways of getting Putin to the negotiating table.”

Lucas said Ukraine’s ability to launch the strikes without SpaceX communication systems is a significant breakthrough. He said Ukraine has consistently innovated around Western dependency, and while Starlink remains useful, the list of must-haves is shrinking.

“Although President Trump once said to Zelensky you just don’t have the cards, actually it’s America that doesn’t have the cards to play if it’s trying to put pressure on Ukraine,” Lucas said.

On Kaliningrad, Lucas described the Russian exclave as a fragile fortress and the Achilles heel of the Russian Federation. He said ground forces there have been cut to pieces in Ukraine and not reconstituted, air defences are depleted, and the Baltic Fleet is the weakest of Russia’s four navies.

He said the Kremlin’s rhetoric about the Suwalki Gap and Narva is a psychological operation designed to make the Baltics appear indefensible. He noted that Poland’s national defence plan includes hitting Kaliningrad hard in any conflict, and that the nuclear warhead storage site at Alexsut is “so secret that you can actually find it on Google Maps.”

Lucas said Russian-speaking populations in the Baltics are not a fifth column, comparing the Kremlin’s claims to the idea that English speakers form a political minority. He said the situation differs fundamentally from Donbas in 2014.

On European security, Lucas said Europe is experiencing what it was like to be Polish in 1945, with its fate decided by big powers at a table where it is not present. He said the comparison with Yalta is apt, and that European dithering, stinginess and complacency have led to this moment.

“It’s mind over matter. They don’t mind and we don’t matter,” he said. “And that’s pretty bad.”

Lucas said Europe can still salvage the situation by reminding the US that it needs Europe as an ally, using its economic weight to help Ukraine and punish Russia, and then turning to China. But he warned that the EU is a legal construct that does not think strategically.

The interview was conducted by Frontline with Kate Gerbeau. Lucas is the author of Fragile Fortress, a book on Kaliningrad to be published this month.

Be First to Comment

Leave a Reply