Press "Enter" to skip to content

Western Leaders Warn Trump Against Treating Putin as a Friend After China Summit

(SHENZHEN, CHINA) – A summit involving Donald Trump, Russian dictator Vladimir Putin and Chinese President Xi Jinping has drawn criticism from European leaders and US senators, who questioned its value and warned against treating Moscow and Beijing as trusted partners. Analysts said the meeting produced little of substance, while concerns grew in Europe that Washington could pursue negotiations over Ukraine without adequate safeguards for Kyiv.

The meeting in Shenzhen, on the sidelines of the Asia-Pacific Economic Cooperation summit, prompted renewed debate over whether Trump’s engagement with Putin could help end Russia’s war against Ukraine or simply improve the Kremlin’s international standing.

German Chancellor Friedrich Merz described the trilateral gathering as a photo session and rejected comparisons with the 1945 Yalta Conference. He said negotiations could succeed only if Ukraine and Europe participated jointly, warning that a Yalta style arrangement would not bring peace.

After a meeting of the Coalition of the Willing in Berlin, Merz said European leaders wanted a just and lasting peace for Ukraine that would provide greater security for Europe and the wider world. He pledged continued support for Kyiv and said Europe would take part in any negotiations.

Merz gave each guest a fragment of the Berlin Wall as a reminder of the consequences of the Yalta agreements for Berlin. Referring to Ronald Reagan’s 1987 speech in the city, he adapted the former US president’s appeal to Mikhail Gorbachev, urging Putin to stop the war and work towards a diplomatic settlement.

Polish Prime Minister Donald Tusk also criticised Trump’s warm reception of Putin. After the US president shook hands with the Russian dictator and called him a friend, Tusk responded: “God save us from such friends.”

Polish Foreign Minister Radosław Sikorski said Trump’s embrace of Putin was causing concern in Warsaw. He questioned how Washington would respond if US and Polish interests came into conflict with Russia’s, asking which relationship Trump would prioritise.

Tusk later said Trump’s belief in Putin’s willingness to negotiate remained strong despite a lack of evidence. Speaking after a telephone conversation with Trump during the Berlin meeting, he said the US president had again expressed optimism about diplomatic efforts following his discussions with Putin and Xi.

“His faith in Vladimir Putin’s good will seems unshakable, although so far no facts confirm it,” Tusk said, according to Polish outlet Onet. He said he hoped Russia would eventually engage seriously in peace talks, but urged allies to judge the Kremlin by its actions rather than its statements.

Trump had joined the Berlin meeting by telephone from Air Force One after leaving China. According to Bloomberg, which cited people familiar with the discussions, he told more than 30 participating leaders that Putin had expressed a desire to end the war. The White House had not responded to a request for comment at the time of the report.

The meeting included European leaders and US envoys Jared Kushner and Steve Witkoff, who are involved in efforts to revive negotiations. The Coalition of the Willing has been discussing ways to protect Ukraine against further Russian aggression after any settlement.

However, European officials remained sceptical about Moscow’s intentions and concerned that Trump might have made concessions during discussions in China. Russia is seeking to broaden negotiations to include security arrangements across Europe, an approach previously regarded by Western officials as unacceptable before a ceasefire.

The United States has urged Russia and Ukraine to reconsider their positions on NATO rules, military assets and the deployment of troops in Europe. American negotiators reportedly view these issues as part of a wider agreement that could also address territorial questions. The United States has asked Kyiv whether it would consider giving up the Donbas region to Russia in exchange for NATO membership.

Ukraine insists that firm security guarantees are essential to deter another Russian attack. European governments have been cautious about linking those guarantees to ceasefire negotiations, while countries bordering Russia reject Putin’s attempts to dictate where NATO can deploy its forces.

Lithuanian President Gitanas Nausėda warned that Putin was distracting Ukraine’s allies while preparing for a winter offensive. European Union leaders have agreed to send national security advisers to future negotiations, seeking to maintain Europe’s involvement and preserve US engagement.

Putin, meanwhile, said he had invited European officials to Moscow to discuss the war. He said Russia would decide how to continue dialogue with Ukraine after understanding what Europe proposed. Bloomberg reported that France, Germany and the United Kingdom had discussed the possibility of meeting Russian representatives.

Trump described his talks with Putin in China as successful and suggested they could help bring the war to an end. “I think certain processes are taking place,” he said. “I think that he — and, hopefully, the other side — would like to see this war come to an end.”

The summit also drew criticism in Washington. Republican Senator John Curtis said Putin and Xi were not US friends and should not be treated as though they shared American values and interests. Democratic Senator Jeanne Shaheen described Putin as a “war criminal and murderer”.

NATO Secretary General Mark Rutte, however, said he saw no problem with talks among the leaders of the three nuclear powers, arguing that communication was important for international security.

Jonathan Eyal of the Royal United Services Institute for Defence and Security Studies said Putin had improved his international image, while Trump had mainly secured a photo opportunity. The Guardian columnist Patrick Wintour also questioned the summit’s significance, noting that its final declaration contained no concrete decisions on Ukraine or Iran.

Western commentators said the Shenzhen meeting was unlikely to become a diplomatic milestone comparable with the Yalta Conference. Their central concern remained whether renewed US engagement with Moscow would produce meaningful steps towards peace, or give the Kremlin greater influence over Ukraine’s future without securing an end to Russian aggression.

Be First to Comment

Leave a Reply