Press "Enter" to skip to content

US Envoys Complete Amateurs, Says Former UK National Security Adviser

(LONDON) – US envoys Steve Witkoff and Jared Kushner are complete amateurs while the Russians are hard eyed professionals who have been playing these games for decades, according to Lord Peter Ricketts, retired senior British diplomat and former national security adviser.

They are out of their depth, the American negotiators, he said.

The comments come as EU leaders sit down in Dublin for their European Political Community summit, while the Russian dictator Vladimir Putin has called on them to choose peace or war.

The comments were made during a meeting in the Kremlin attended by Witkoff and Kushner, where Putin also warned that any foreign troops deployed to Ukraine would be targeted by Russian forces.

“In that latter case they would be a legitimate target for us and the war would immediately resume,” Putin said.

Ricketts said Putin is playing mind games.

“Let’s just remind ourselves, Europe was at peace until Putin went to war with Ukraine five years ago. Europe has always stood for peace. It’s the Russians who have been the aggressors. And for Putin to kind of say these things to try and put the blame almost on the Europeans for what he has done in Ukraine seems to me absolutely extraordinary,” he said.

He said it is also a glimpse into what Putin means when Russia talks about a new European security architecture, which has a reasonably seductive ring.

“What he means is he wants a band of weak states around Russia’s border, particularly Ukraine. He wants to oppose Ukraine’s right to have any foreign forces on their soil. And yet, after what Ukraine’s been through, of course they’re going to want security guarantees after a peace settlement. So we absolutely have to call out this behaviour by Putin to try to shift the blame onto the Europeans,” Ricketts said.

On the question of peacekeeping troops from Europe to help maintain security in Ukraine, Ricketts said this is a red line for Putin.

He said it feels contradictory because Putin is sending North Koreans into war with Ukraine.

“It’s fine in Putin’s mind for him to go to war with Ukraine, to smash the country up, to use Iranian drones, to use North Korean troops. And yet he wants to exclude Ukraine from having the right of any sovereign country to decide how to protect its territory after a peace settlement,” Ricketts said.

He said Putin wants to extend the same sort of prohibitions wider in Europe.

“I’m sure he’ll want to argue that Ukraine shouldn’t join NATO. Probably Georgia shouldn’t join NATO. Maybe that other NATO forces shouldn’t be deployed on the territory of the eastern member states of NATO. This is what he means. He doesn’t mean a Europe free in a new security architecture. It means a Europe where Russia has a right to dictate the security arrangements of countries near its border and that can never be acceptable. So it’s just one more reason why we shouldn’t be taken in by Putin. The Russians are not interested in peace on any terms that the Ukrainians could agree or that would leave Europe safe. Unfortunately, therefore we’ve got to stand strong,” he said.

Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelenskyy expressed some bemusement over the idea that the US approach of discussing a new security order with Russia was a bit strange.

He said effectively that Russia and the US would like Europe to be part of peace negotiations and in exchange the sweetener to Russia was going to be potentially a seat at the table when talking about post war security arrangements, whether there are troops on the ground or whether Russia wants to use border nations to their advantage.

Zelenskyy sees through this but rightly says Europe is already involved in these peace negotiations.

Ricketts said Europe is not involved at the moment.

European representatives did go to the Abu Dhabi talks a few days ago between the Russians and the Ukrainians with the Americans as go betweens. They did not get in the room. They were not part of the discussion. They were only there to be told what had happened afterwards.

They were not in Moscow.

“I’m afraid Witkoff and Kushner are complete amateurs whereas the Russians are hard eyed professionals who’ve been playing these games for decades. They’re out of their depth, I’m afraid, the American negotiators,” Ricketts said.

He said Europe should be part of a discussion because it is European security that is on the table.

“We have the prospect of Putin and Trump meeting next week. And that’s a very worrying prospect because I’m afraid Trump after his thrashing in the midterm elections will want to cut a dash as a world leader alongside Putin, disposing of the fate of nations without any consultation with Europe. So we do need to worry about these continuing discussions that are mainly held with these two amateur American envoys and really do need proper European voice in the discussion,” he said.

He said it cannot be just one European.

“We need to have a group of European countries who are fully engaged in these negotiations because it’s all our security on the table,” Ricketts said.

On the question of whether there could be a single European envoy, Ricketts said he does not think there is a single person who can do it.

“What do we mean by Europe? Do we mean the European Union? No, we can’t mean that because the UK is not part of it. Do we mean European members of NATO? No, because there are Europeans who are not in NATO. I don’t see how there is a single figure unlike the US or Russia. We’re not one country. We’re a federation of 30, 35 different countries and I don’t think there’s any process by which people would agree there should be one leader,” he said.

“If there was one, the French would want it to be Emmanuel Macron. You can be sure of that. Most countries would want their leader. So I think it has to be a small group of leaders, one of whom could be representing the EU, one NATO countries in Europe. It’s got to be something like that. I don’t think there’s a single figure who can do it. And I think it’s no good the Americans coming to us and saying, ‘Who is the European who can represent you?’ Because we’re not a single state,” Ricketts said.

Be First to Comment

Leave a Reply