Press "Enter" to skip to content
Putin Seeks Trump and Xi Summit on Ukraine War

Russian Bloggers: War Not Going to Plan, NATO Would Be Worse

(KYIV) – Russian military bloggers have questioned recent comments by the Russian dictator Vladimir Putin. The bloggers, who are fiercely supportive of the Kremlin’s military, are dismissive of European fighting power.

Putin claimed Moscow does not want war with NATO but that its troops are ready to win if forced into one.

The Russian military’s failure to defeat Ukraine after nearly five years of a war that was supposed to last a week is evidence that its fighting capacity is not as capable as the Kremlin wants people to believe, the bloggers said.

They added that battlefield realities exposing real gaps in the army’s capacity are not going to change any time soon.

Igor “Strelkov” Girkin, a former FSB officer sentenced in 2024 to four years in prison on extremism charges, said the Russian leader was “imagining things”.

Writing in a prison cell letter published on Monday, Girkin said: “I don’t know why Vladimir Vladimirovich decided that we are ready for war with the whole of Europe, if we even, excuse the expression, cannot defeat so-called Ukraine in five years.”

He continued: “If our cities are being attacked and bombed by the enemy for the fifth year of the war, and under serious attacks, serious bombings, civilians die in large numbers, our large and strategically important industrial enterprises are burned and destroyed – why did Vladimir Vladimirovich decide that we are ready for war with all of Europe?”

“I honestly don’t know. Most likely, this is just a rhetorical phrase to reassure himself.”

Putin, speaking to reporters in Moscow on 29th October, said Russia’s defences are strong and fully capable of taking on NATO.

He stated: “Many [in Europe] are talking about preparing for a war by 2030. Is it right or wrong? First of all, we are prepared. But we want no war with Europe.”

“If any of them want it, let them prepare. But they have not reached their goal of inflicting strategic defeat on Russia, and it is unlikely this will be possible by 2030 either.”

Aleksandr Khodakovsky, a former Ukrainian special forces commander who defected to fight for the Kremlin in 2014, said Moscow faces a hostile Europe and needs peace soon.

He said Russian military power has clear limits.

In a Sunday analysis on Telegram, he wrote: “What should worry us most is not how the West assesses our ability to resist it, but a real assessment of our own potential and our own capabilities.”

“To fight or to make peace is up to us to decide, and we must decide based on our own understanding of the consequences of war or peace.”

“The war must be stopped, because it is obvious that the expectations of the war [quick defeat of Ukraine] gave way to the consequences [powerful European opposition] that the war inevitably generates.”

Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelensky told the country’s military on Sunday that October 2026 saw the highest numbers of Russian casualties for the entire war.

He added that in that month, like the September preceding it, invading Russian forces lost more territory than they gained.

The pro-war but Kremlin-critical milblogger channel Ofitser na Peredovoi, or Officer at the Front, confirmed in an 31st October post that minor Russian advances at the price of at-times crushing losses are common.

It repeated a frequent complaint that mid-level officers ignore actual combat conditions to report victories to the Kremlin.

A daily sitrep said: “Heavy fighting continues at the front. Reports of advances by a few hundred meters or the repelling of counterattacks do not, in themselves, signify a real shift in the situation.”

“What matters are confirmed outcomes: the ability to hold ground, the effective resupply of units, and the genuine security of the rear.”

“Official briefings may cite kilometers gained or the number of targets intercepted, but the ultimate cost of these events is measured in human lives.”

Meanwhile, Ukrainian Unmanned Aerial Vehicle (UAV) strikes continued deep inside Russia, setting a major oil refinery in the Samara region ablaze.

The pro-war Telegram channel Arkhangel Spetsnaza said on 30th October: “For the second day in a row, Ukrainian forces have carried out massive raids on Russian rear areas. Yesterday saw over 1,000 UAVs, and today, the situation is the same.”

“Drones were intercepted as far away as the Kostroma region last night – a highly unusual occurrence…A key target of the attack was the Samara region – specifically the Novokuibyshevsk oil refinery – where, according to Ukrainian sources, 11 separate fires have been reported.”

According to a March analysis by the Latvia-based investigative outlet Re:Baltika, there is general consensus among Z-bloggers that Russia and NATO are already in direct conflict.

However, the likely outcome is unclear given Russia’s inability to defeat much smaller Ukraine.

The article said: “Confidence about the outcome is far less uniform. Some claim Russia’s army, hardened by the war in Ukraine, is ready to prevail.”

“[But] Many others raise a more uncomfortable question: if Russia has spent years struggling to defeat Ukraine – advancing slowly against an opponent backed by only partial Western support – what would happen if it faced the full force of NATO?”

Be First to Comment

Leave a Reply