(ABU DHABI) – Talks between Ukrainian, Russian and American delegations in Abu Dhabi have concluded without agreement on a ceasefire, with Ukraine prioritising the release of prisoners as its sole humanitarian objective.
Air raid sirens wailed in Kyiv throughout the morning as negotiations were underway. Russian attacks this week have left hopes of real progress low, with energy blackouts and water supplies interrupted across the city.
In Abu Dhabi, Europe was shut out of the main talks with Russia and instead held its own meeting with Ukraine, led by Jared Kushner, the son in law of US President Donald Trump. Kushner said there were “positive signs from both sides” that they want to see an end to the war.
The delegations faced a diplomatic impasse: Ukraine demands a ceasefire before discussing territory and security guarantees, while Russia insists those issues are preconditions to any ceasefire.
Lukianivska is one of the most targeted areas of central Kyiv. Residents assume Russian forces are targeting a complex there in the belief that military or underground activity is ongoing. The building was damaged this summer, yet a marketplace operates there daily and normal life continues.
There is no sign in Kyiv of optimism that the talks will lead to lasting peace, with widespread scepticism that the Russian dictator Vladimir Putin wants one.
Ukraine’s President Volodymyr Zelenskyy was in Denmark accepting £500 million (€580 million, $630 million) in military aid. He said the Abu Dhabi talks had been constructive and substantive, with much detail on security guarantees. He added that the priority was the release of prisoners.
Ukrainian officials said the focus was humanitarian: how to bring back Ukrainian civilians and exchange captured soldiers.
In the Solomianskyi district of Kyiv, the World Central Kitchen aid agency is feeding people who have no way of cooking for themselves. On Saturday, another air strike, the third in this area, destroyed gas, electricity and water supplies.
Vera, an English teacher, was caring for her parents when she received a call saying her flat had been damaged. She had lived there since birth and attended the kindergarten next door.
The kindergarten is completely destroyed. Had the attack occurred on a weekday, the playground would have been full of children.
“We’re waiting for it to stop as soon as possible,” Vera said. “We’re suffering. I’m not going to do anything in my flat because there is no sense. How can I do something if they are bombing? There is no point rebuilding it.”
Ukraine’s air force said it shot down 135 Russian drones overnight, but 19 landed, including one in Sumy in the north east. This is the backdrop to the talks in Abu Dhabi: low trust and growing fear of what winter will bring.
Lithuania’s former foreign minister, Gabrielius Landsbergis, and Alexander Kar, a former adviser to Ukraine’s defence minister and now executive director of the Centre for Defence Strategies, discussed the negotiations.
Kar described Russia’s demand for security guarantees as “ridiculous”. He noted that since 1991 Russia has fought wars in Moldova, Georgia and Chechnya, and launched a second war against Ukraine in 2022. “Nobody is attacking Russia,” he said. “Nobody is threatening Russia.”
He said Ukraine wanted to join NATO because of Russia’s belligerent policies. He described the talks as the wrong format to end the war.
Kar said Ukraine would welcome a ceasefire because Russia cannot achieve significant gains on the battlefield, but Russia has refused one. Russia is able to inflict great pain on the civilian population by destroying energy infrastructure, which is why Ukraine is negotiating for a ceasefire and possible compromises.
He said Russia believes the talks can undermine European support for Ukraine and widen the gap between the United States and Europe. “It’s a part of a war rather than seeking a diplomatic solution,” he said.
Landsbergis said similar talks in the past produced prisoner exchanges but no movement on peace. He does not believe there will be progress now. He said the reasons for the talks differ: for the West they are partially performative, a ritual; for Russia they are a way to buy time and pretend to care while its goals remain unchanged.
He said Ukraine is the only genuinely interested party and that Zelenskyy has always been clear he would agree to a ceasefire. “It might feel very lonely for him at that table,” Landsbergis said.
Kushner said he would try to involve the Europeans, perhaps tomorrow. Landsbergis said the war cannot be settled without Europe, which is footing the bill. He cited €90 billion (£78 billion, $97 billion) lent to Ukraine last year as the way Ukraine funds its defence today. If Europe stopped funding, Ukraine would face an almost unbearable situation.
He said continued European funding would send a message that Europe and Ukraine still have leverage against Russia. No real solution can be found without European involvement.
On American leverage and the effect of Trump’s midterm election defeat, Kar said it is minimal at this stage. The United States has used almost every instrument to pressure Ukraine to give up: stopping financing, halting intelligence sharing, and restricting Ukraine’s use of Starlink.
He said there is little left Washington can threaten Ukraine with. Asked whether Ukraine is seeking an alternative to Starlink using Israeli or European systems, Kar said it is possible but will take time. Meanwhile, more Ukrainians may die and less Russian infrastructure may be damaged. “Time is of crucial importance,” he said.
Footage and reporting from the Abu Dhabi talks and Kyiv strikes was provided by Channel 4 News.

Be First to Comment