(LONDON, UNITED KINGDOM) – Ukraine’s continued deep battle operations, particularly strikes on Russian oil refineries, could generate sufficient societal and political pressure to bring the Russian dictator Vladimir Putin to negotiations, according to a former British Army commander.
Major General Chip Chapman, former British Army commander and author of Notes from a Small Military, said Ukraine appears to be using Israeli satellite communications to outlast Starlink restrictions from Elon Musk and the US administration.
This leverage could force Putin to negotiate on societal endurance and political resilience, he said.
Speaking on day 1,722 of the full scale invasion, Chapman assessed the diplomatic landscape, including bilateral and trilateral talks in Abu Dhabi.
He said the Americans first sat down with European leaders and the Ukrainians to agree a security framework underpinning NATO’s importance and a NATO Article Five or Article Four style scenario with Ukraine.
Then the Ukrainians, Russians and Americans met, with the same team as before. Chapman said the Americans appear to be getting played and there is no agreement.
Russia is trying to cash in its chips at the strategic level. Militarily it is playing for marginal gains, but politically it wants low cost and high gains.
The Americans seem to be enabling that, appearing to throw Ukraine under a bus, he said.
A major flaw in the approach of US envoys Jared Kushner and Steve Witkoff is that they view the conflict through a geoeconomic prism, believing Russia can be combined with the West through economic incentives.
Chapman said this is absolutely wrong. Russia is not a market optimising force but a political identity actor.
Russia has introduced the security architecture aspect, a larger way of saying a return to pre 1997 NATO expansion. Chapman said discussing this is wrong because Russia already ruined the security architecture underpinned by the Helsinki Final Act of 1975.
In doctrinal terms, Russia should have no veto right over anything in Europe.
The Helsinki Final Act included respect for sovereignty, refraining from the threat or use of force, the inviability of frontiers, territorial integrity and the peaceful settlement of disputes.
Chapman warned that a dictated peace by America and Russia, or a trilateral including China, would be detrimental to everyone. European security must include agency for Ukraine and for Europe itself.
He recalled a 1943 book stating that the borderland between Russia and the Atlantic states would be settled either by consent or by political violence, dictation and war. Current events are moving towards dictation.
US National Security Advisor Jonathan Powell recently said there was good news and bad news: light at the end of the tunnel, but no tunnel. Chapman disagreed, saying there are two tunnels.
One is the surrender or capitulation path, potentially a Carthaginian peace, which the Americans want Ukraine to take. The other is a just or durable peace, which Europeans and Ukrainians want.
The two remain far apart, and there is a chasm between what both teams want, he said.
Pressure remains on Ukraine, with America wanting concessions and Russia being rewarded. The approach is asymmetrical.
Chapman does not expect anything substantive from Abu Dhabi beyond marginal items such as prisoner exchanges.
If anyone believes the campaign is ending, it will continue into 2027, bringing Russia’s theory of victory into play.
President Volodymyr Zelenskyy gave an interview discussing Russian claims presented to the Americans, including that Russia had captured about 50% more of the Donbas, particularly Donetsk oblast, than it actually has.
Zelenskyy said Ukrainian troops are in that area, asking how Russia can claim otherwise when it knows Ukraine knows the claims are wrong.
Chapman said Putin is likely being belligerent in front of Witkoff and Kushner, who are diplomatically naive, and is perpetuating the lie.
The casualties are somewhat irrelevant because enormous Russian losses are acceptable if they secure political objectives. All wars are fought for political objectives.
The Institute for the Study of War reported that Russia had particularly costly months in September and October. In October, casualty figures reached 58,000 dead or wounded, the biggest losses in any month, alongside a net loss of territory.
Although Russia retains offensive capability and local defensive capability around Dopra Pylia, wars are won at operational and strategic level.
Russia’s new theory of victory has three parts. The first is sustaining the war. Russia’s new 2027 budget allocates $202 billion equivalent in purchasing power parity to defence, 41% more than 2026.
Russia will make sacrifices elsewhere, including a 15.2% reduction to societal policies. Defence will account for 44% of the budget.
Chapman noted the UK spent about 45% of GDP on defence by the end of the Second World War. Moscow is preparing its economy for war sustainment and will not make political concessions to end the war.
The second part is infrastructure cost on Ukraine, freezing Ukrainians into surrender this winter. Ukrainian intelligence reports that Russia will shortly target food industry silos, dairies and meat and poultry processing plants.
Combined with limited electricity and pressure on water distribution, this amounts to a Syria style application of war, making city life untenable and potentially triggering major population flows westward, including immigration flows.
Russia believes it can break the will of the Ukrainian people. Chapman does not think it can, but noted that armies do not fight wars, nations do, and the will of the people must be sustained.
In the cognitive domain, Russia is in the ascendancy in its relationship with America and appears to be winning the strategic political battle, at least until a new Congress convenes.
The legislature may restore balance to the trinity of American power. There may be amelioration on sanctioning Russia and Iran through the Lindsey Graham Act, which passed Congress on 18th September but was overturned by Trump on 18th October.
Chapman described the subsequent talk of buying diesel and oil from Russia as a complete volte face.
A new Pentagon European force profile is expected in the coming weeks, which will indicate whether the US intends to withdraw and how that affects Russian demands for a European security architecture.
Russia has placed a new European security architecture at the centre of negotiations, piling new demands on top of others.
European Commission President Kaja Kallas reiterated that Russia is showing no good will and is pretending to negotiate while intensifying strikes against civilian energy infrastructure. She described Russia’s actions as increasingly kinetic rather than merely hybrid, linked to broader imperial rather than purely territorial ambitions.
Chapman said Putin’s relationship with Donald Trump matters immensely because Trump takes the great man theory of international relations, believing key leaders determine history.
Trump likes authoritarian strongmen and would like to be one, though he cannot be. He has always been a disruptor in politics, and it remains to be seen whether he becomes an insurgent in foreign policy over the next two years.
The president has more leeway in foreign policy than Congress, but appropriations come from Congress and the Senate, which caveats him.
Democrats now in the ascendancy can support Ukraine because they control the budget and appropriations. Chapman hopes for amelioration there.
Kallas has been realistic about Russian foreign policy, particularly as former prime minister of Estonia. She has no illusions about revisionist imperial Russia under Putin.
She has quoted Andrei Gromyko, former Soviet foreign minister, who described three parts to Russian negotiating tactics: demand the maximum, make threats and never give an inch because there are always useful idiots in the West who will give in.
By the end, Russia obtains a third or half of something it did not have before.
There is a sequencing problem. Ukraine and Europe have always said there should be a ceasefire at the contact line followed by negotiations. Russia rejects this.
Russia’s position is that a future security architecture, the territorial issue and security guarantees for Russia must be settled before a ceasefire.
The two positions remain unbridgeable, which is why Abu Dhabi will produce no real denouement. Multiple negotiations, not a two day session, will be needed.
An academic from Moscow said Putin is focusing on holding Europe in position and waiting for French elections, hoping Marine Le Pen will change Europe’s view on supporting Ukraine and cause difficulties, allowing Russia to advance its strategic aims.
Chapman said this is a concern because the final part of Russia’s theory of victory is waiting for political fatigue in the West.
Russia’s grand strategic objective is to regain lost territory and spheres of influence, returning to Putin’s 2005 Munich Security Conference statement that the demise of the Soviet Union was the greatest geopolitical disaster of the 20th century.
Beneath that, Russia’s strategic objectives are to weaken and divide the EU and to weaken and divide NATO. Populist governments in Europe would help divide the EU and the unity needed to support Ukraine.
Ukraine can only survive through unity and through economic, humanitarian, financial and military support.
At operational level, Ukraine continues to attack Russian oil and gas infrastructure. The Russian central bank continues to warn about the impact on the economy.
Questions remain over whether Russia can supply the diesel it agreed to provide to Trump, because it is having to import diesel itself. Winter fuel allocated to the front line is being moved to St Petersburg and Moscow, so troops are not receiving it.
Russian casualty figures on the front line are hitting new records. Ukraine has the tactical initiative and appears to be advancing slowly, and has the operational initiative.
Chapman recalled a 1975 meeting between an American colonel and a Vietnamese general. The colonel said America never defeated Vietnam on the battlefield. The general replied that this may be true but it is irrelevant.
Wars are won at the strategic level. Russian casualties are piling up, but they are irrelevant in terms of the inequality of sacrifice.
It is not the Russian ethnic areas being affected, nor the professional classes in Moscow and St Petersburg. It is contract soldiers from poor parts of the Russian Federation: Buryatia, Tuva, Dagestan and Siberia.
There is potential for a crack there, but daily life must remain as normal as possible in key core constituencies to enable societal endurance and political resilience.
So far, deaths and sacrifice have not been in politically influential areas. But if Ukraine’s deep battle continues to be significant and successful, particularly refinery strikes using Israeli satellite communications, this could provide leverage in bringing Putin to negotiations.
Chapman said this may be naive, as it views the situation through a Western prism, a fatal attribution bias. Putin is so invested in the sunk cost basis of the war that he must continue to achieve something he can sell as political victory.
Recording on 11th November, Armistice Day, Chapman noted there are 1.6 million dead or wounded on the Russian side and at least half a million on the Ukrainian side. Over two million casualties, with deaths alone exceeding British and American losses in the Second World War.
Putin keeps the statistic irrelevant from a military perspective by framing it politically. Since 2014 and Crimea, he has claimed to have gathered in the Russian people.
At Valdai recently he said there is only one people, the Russian people, and Ukrainians are Russian, mirroring his July 2021 essay that preceded the 2022 assault.
If Putin can achieve political success, minimally the Donbas, he can sell it as victory. He has said that if he does not get the Donbas, they will hang him. He knows he needs at least the Donbas and some security architecture change or veto on NATO forces.
In an authoritarian regime, he can sell that as victory, and the dead will be placed on the plinths of the glorious dead.
Chapman quoted John Donne: any man’s death diminishes me, for I am of mankind. Therefore, seek not to know for whom the bell tolls, it tolls for thee. This is true at an individual level but not at a political collective level when a rationalist Russian imperialist is in charge in Moscow.
On territorial realities, pre Abu Dhabi talks included redrawing administrative boundaries of Kharkiv and Donetsk oblasts, likely along the contact line, which Zelenskyy had said could form the basis for a ceasefire and political settlement. This appears to have disappeared.
Chapman said the quid pro quo was that Ukraine would retain some or more of Zaporizhzhia and Kherson. The four oblasts were deemed Russian when legislated in the Duma, and Putin cannot concede any in negotiations.
There has been talk of a de jure versus de facto approach. Putin has said Ukraine should accept territorial realities, meaning Russian boots on the ground. Freezing at the contact line would be de facto recognition of where Russia is, but de jure the territory is not legally Russia’s under international law.
On whether Putin has boxed himself in and cannot afford peace, Chapman said the object of war is a better peace, but from whose perspective and whose rules apply. Putin still believes his rules will apply and that he is in the ascendancy.
Chapman does not think Putin is defeated, nor is Ukraine. As long as the West supports Ukraine, it has a chance of success. War is the most complex activity in the world with many variables, and linear predictions of when and where it will end are naive.
The interview was broadcast by Frontline, produced by Times Radio.

Be First to Comment