Press "Enter" to skip to content

Oil Traders Refuse Russian Diesel Despite Trump Putin Deal

(ABU DHABI, UAE) – US led trilateral talks between Ukraine, Russia and the United States have opened in Abu Dhabi with expectations low, as a leading academic warned that Kyiv must survive the winter before a changed US Congress can shift the balance of pressure on Moscow.

Professor Scott Lucas of University College Dublin told Frontline that unless a quick settlement emerges from the talks, which he doubts, the focus should shift to 2027, when a new US domestic political situation could favour Ukraine.

“If Ukraine can survive the winter, then it’s even more pressure on the Russians,” he said.

The talks began on 10th November 2026, with US envoys Steve Witkoff and Jared Kushner mediating.

Witkoff and Kushner met European and NATO officials before sitting down with Russian and Ukrainian delegations, stating that Euroatlantic security guarantees would be underpinned by NATO.

Lucas said Kushner and Witkoff may be “in over their heads,” noting that NATO’s central role in security guarantees has always been unacceptable to Moscow.

He traced the current diplomatic push to October 2025, when the first sweeping US sanctions against Russia were imposed after the Russian dictator Vladimir Putin overplayed his hand at the Alaska summit.

Witkoff later met Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelensky and asked why Kyiv would not give up the rest of the Donetsk region.

Lucas said this showed a shallow grasp of Ukrainian society, noting that Zelensky’s first language is Russian.

By late 2025, Witkoff and Kushner sat down with Kirill Dmitriev, head of the Russian Direct Investment Fund, who presented a 28 point ultimatum.

The ultimatum demanded Ukraine give up Donetsk and Luhansk, accept limits on its military and restrict its relationship with NATO.

In early September 2026, Witkoff and Kushner travelled to Moscow, where the Russians put more than $50 billion (£39.5 billion) of deals on the table.

These included the sale of overseas assets of Lukoil at $22 billion (£17.4 billion), a $25 billion (£19.8 billion) gas distribution plant in Alaska secretly overseen by Russian company Novatek, and the potential renovation of Nord Stream.

Dmitriev was later in Washington last week, nominally for a Melania Trump arranged local ceasefire in Oleshky, but he met Donald Trump.

Lucas said the US is pushing territorial concessions on one side of the ledger while offering what are called NATO five type security guarantees on the other.

He warned that Kushner has spoken of “mutual security guarantees,” which is a red flag because Russia’s vision in 2021 was for NATO to withdraw from its eastern flank.

Russia also wants limits on forces in those areas and a return to pre 1997 borders.

Lucas noted that Kushner dropped a reference to “territorial integrity” in a social media post between last weekend and yesterday, replacing it with “independent governance.”

Ukraine has made clear it will accept a ceasefire on current front lines with no legal recognition of Russian occupied territory.

Lucas said the first question Ukraine and Europe should put to Russian Deputy Foreign Minister Sergei Ryabkov is whether Moscow agrees to a ceasefire on the current front lines.

If the Russians will not make that commitment, “the talks are a non starter,” he said.

He described the talks as “talks about talks” that will not produce a settlement today.

On the battlefield, Lucas said Ukrainian forces have the initiative and are beginning to push the Russians back, but Putin may not be aware due to false reporting.

He noted a shift in Russia’s tone last month when Moscow suddenly said any settlement must involve all of Europe.

A 90 minute call between Putin, Norwegian Prime Minister Jonas Gahr Store and Finnish President Alexander Stubb went nowhere, with Putin lecturing them on medieval history.

Lucas said Putin does this to assert that Ukraine is part of Russia, which is a non starter.

The Russians then said Europe had no role within 24 to 48 hours, before European officials from Italy, Germany, France, the UK, the EU and NATO arrived in Abu Dhabi.

Lucas said the Russians realise they cannot get a deal with the US over the heads of Ukraine and Europe.

He expects Washington and Moscow to try to work on the Europeans to pressure Kyiv into concessions, with security guarantees as the carrot.

Lucas said European officials will ask for specifics on what security guarantees mean for ground forces, air deployments, air cover and intelligence arrangements.

He dismissed Kushner’s suggestion of returning to the NATO Russia Council arrangement, which was suspended after the 2022 invasion.

“You can’t just go back to that arrangement in the face of the fact that Russia shattered that arrangement on February the 24th, 2022,” he said.

Lucas said a senior academic in Moscow told him Russia is waiting for French elections and that Europe’s direction may change, specifically mentioning Marine Le Pen becoming the next French president.

He said Russia always looks for a divided Europe and will feed division with propaganda and disinformation.

But he does not see France breaking away from support of Ukraine in the short term, noting that President Emmanuel Macron has personally invested himself in that position.

Macron will remember being played by Putin before the invasion, Lucas said.

He described Russian efforts to divide Europe as a longer term game, and said he would be surprised if Moscow has any success this week in breaking resistance to its maximum demands.

On the $50 billion in deals, Lucas said US oil traders are refusing to buy Russian diesel despite the reported Trump Putin deal.

He attributed this to the US midterm elections, where the Democrats won both houses.

Representative Jamie Raskin of Maryland put down markers that any firm touching Russian diesel purchases would face punitive action.

Two tankers have changed course, one heading for Brazil, another to an unspecified destination, a third is idle and a fourth is proceeding towards the United States but awaiting orders.

Lucas said Trump undermined sanctions with the diesel deal and defied Congress by refusing to implement additional sanctions passed in September, the so called Graham bill for 500% tariffs on Russia and 100% on its top oil customers.

He said both Democrats and Republicans are building momentum against Trump’s line, citing bipartisan concern over the suspension of early warning intelligence and the cutting off of Elon Musk’s Starshield.

Hearings are expected in January into those decisions and potentially into Trump family wealth.

Lucas said US officials leaked information about the deals to the media, indicating serious internal concern.

Dmitriev, as head of the Russian Direct Investment Fund, invited Americans to invest, claiming up to $14 trillion could be made, including in rare earth minerals.

Lucas detailed business ties around the Lukoil overseas assets sale, which will go to a consortium including a major Trump donor who gave $2 million recently and three Middle Eastern businessmen.

Two of those businessmen are linked to Witkoff’s sons and Donald Trump’s sons through the cryptocurrency venture World Liberty Financial.

The third is linked with Kushner for a high end resort on an island off Albania that sparked nationwide protests.

The Alaska gas distribution deal worth $25 billion involved Gentry Beach, a friend of Donald Trump Jr since university.

Lucas also cited a Putin political fixer who was given Russia’s largest auto dealership and a string of online gambling firms, who paid for Donald Trump Jr’s wedding reception on a Caribbean island and took Donald on a hunting trip in Mongolia where endangered species were killed.

“Nobody gets anything for free,” Lucas said, adding that Europe, Ukraine and Congress know the business ties are extensive.

He said unless there is a quick settlement, “bring on 2027 because you’ve got to change domestic situation in the United States.”

On humanitarian diplomacy, Zelensky awarded Melania Trump a national honour for her role in brokering a local ceasefire in Oleshky, a Russian occupied town in the Kherson region.

Lucas said the Pope’s representation was decisive in allowing civilians to leave, but Russia played up Melania’s interest to influence Trump.

He noted that in July 2025, Russia launched a massive aerial strike on Kyiv on American Independence Day, which turned Trump against the Kremlin for some time after Melania showed him photographs.

Ukrainian human rights ombudsman Dmytro Lubinets and Russia’s nominal ombudsman travelled with Melania, but so did Dmitriev.

Lucas said around 800 people got out of Oleshky, and if Melania had a role, even a minor one compared to the Pope, she deserves credit.

But he cautioned against claims that the local ceasefire shows a wider settlement is possible.

“Oleshky was a particular case where both sides were trying to get some political leverage out of it,” he said.

On the winter ahead, Lucas said Ukraine must survive, with preparations needed for air defences, the energy sector, the electricity grid and financial support.

He cited a gap of around 70 billion euros (€70 billion / $81 billion / £61 billion) highlighted by German Chancellor Friedrich Merz.

Lucas warned that Russia will keep trying to force Ukraine into a corner through aerial attacks, and Europe through grey zone attacks, cyber warfare, threats to maritime security and drone incursions.

He said activists in Russia, Ireland, the UK, Europe and the United States believe the Kremlin deserves security guarantees.

“Hope for a glimmer of the best, but prepare for the realistic,” he said.

“The realistic is this winter, I think, is Putin’s last best shot to force Ukraine surrender. And that will not come through negotiations. That will come through the aerial attacks.”

 

Be First to Comment

Leave a Reply