Press "Enter" to skip to content

Putin Has No Chance of Winning War Right Now, Says Analyst

(WARSAW) – The Russian dictator Vladimir Putin does not want to end the war in Ukraine and will only do so when he feels he has almost no other option, according to Robert Pszczel, senior fellow at the Centre for Eastern Studies.

Putin believes, wrongly in Pszczel’s view, that he could win. One reason is that pressure is not being applied on Russia from all sides, while Ukrainians are capable of taking down a Russian frigate 1,000 km from the Ukrainian border.

The situation on the front line is not good for Russia, which is suffering extremely heavy losses. Ukraine is also suffering enormous destruction from the barbaric way in which this war is being fought.

The most important factor is that Putin believes he can outlast Ukraine and its backers. The big problem in this puzzle is the position of the United States.

Pszczel said the so-called peace talks are not serious because the Russians are not serious about them. The history is wrong from the beginning because the United States is acting as a mediator when it should be on Ukraine’s side.

That was accepted by the Ukrainians because they rely on US support progressively less but it remains important enough for Ukraine to go through the hoops.

For Europeans, the main objective and most important achievement would be to be at the table. If it is about ending the war, they should have been there from the beginning. Europeans not only support Ukraine but pay and do many things the US is no longer doing, and Ukraine recognises that.

Pszczel said Europeans can advise the Ukrainians but they are the ones who have to make the decisions. If there are issues concerning territorial concessions, this is only for Ukraine to decide.

The Russians have a completely different objective. These so-called peace talks are a pretext to start talking about the things they tried to do many years ago, at latest in 2021.

Putin wants essentially the US out in terms of military presence. He wants all sorts of restrictions, and the appetite grows. Putin’s adviser said yesterday that he wants Finland to withdraw from NATO.

These are old, stale, boring and predictable Russian demands: restrictions on the size of troops, no military bases and no allied bases.

The answer given in 2021 by all allies was no. Russia is not in a better position today to demand this. It would essentially be about recreating some sort of Soviet empire with special rights for Russia.

Russia is aggressive. European demands as stated are about reparations and about Russia having to change to be readmitted into the civilised world.

The problem is that Moscow has suddenly got new hopes because of a very strange approach from the US administration. It seems clear from many statements that there is sympathy towards Putin and that Trump does not really feel the same way about Ukraine.

There is also a question of allied responsibilities, and the two so-called negotiators have no clue. Most people assume they want some sort of peace deal so Trump could say he is the greatest deal maker in history.

They do not really care about Ukraine or about Europeans. This game has to stop.

Pszczel said the Russians are in a hurry because something has happened in the US and it is not clear how the situation will evolve. Trump remains president and has responsibility for foreign security policy, but politically the situation would be completely different.

Letters from Democratic congressmen in the US say this will not fly, and they would like to extract some concession.

Pszczel said it is incomprehensible why Europeans are spending all this time in an inelegant game of who should lead. The people who represent Europe should speak on its behalf.

This is silly and not serious. We are in a very dangerous moment because mistakes can be made which will have consequences. The best move would be for Europeans to sit down in NATO and come up with a position saying this is unacceptable.

On the question of US military presence in Poland, Pszczel said people make a fundamental mistake by equating the current US position with a lack of one. The US position is volatile to put it mildly and is not driven by US interests.

There are serious discussions about a permanent US military base in Poland. There is also a review and most likely there will be fewer US troops in Europe, but not everybody will leave and there might be more in Poland.

General Green Cavage epitomises this schizophrenia. The fury victory he presented is a deterrence message that the US is ready to defend and that Russia should not even think about it. The US still has more troops in the eastern flank than other west European countries who speak big but whose reality is a bit different.

This positive reality can be undermined by this strange desire which has nothing to do with US interests. Russia is helping Iran to attack US troops in the Middle East. Russia is an ally of China, which is one of the main reasons the US should be thinking seriously about moving some assets from Europe. This does not add up.

Something has to give. This is a dangerous moment because the people in Washington have to stop it.

If Ukrainians accept that the US still leads this strange peace talks about Ukraine, that is up to them. But there has been no agreement and no mandate to allow anybody, particularly Kushner or Witkoff, who really do not know anything about Russia.

Pszczel said we have to say no, this cannot go on like this. Prime Minister Donald Tusk said it very clearly: we will not allow anybody in Russia or in Washington to decide about security.

There has to be a serious conversation in the US itself because this process is harming US interests and credibility. It is time to change the narrative.

Pszczel said he does not know what will emerge from the summit in Dublin but he hopes it is not the acceptance of this strange rule set in Moscow and partially in Washington.

Prime Minister Donald Tusk said Poland and other European partners were briefed late Thursday in Dublin on the outcome of US talks with Vladimir Putin. Washington is promising European involvement in future negotiations while Moscow is pushing for a wider security agreement that could affect NATO’s eastern flank.

The interview was broadcast by TVP World’s World Talks programme.

Be First to Comment

Leave a Reply