(BERLIN, GERMANY) – More than 412,000 Russian soldiers have been killed in the war in Ukraine, according to leaked records from Russia’s state statistics agency, Rosstat.
The figures have not been independently verified. The Guardian reports that the true death toll could be closer to 500,000.
Some months saw more than 500 Russian soldiers killed every day. The losses have fallen disproportionately on Russia’s poorer and more remote regions.
Janis Kluge, head of the Eastern Europe and Eurasia research division at the German Institute for International and Security Affairs, said he is confident the leaked files are genuine Rosstat data.
He told DW News that several parts of the data can be verified easily, and the picture they present is real.
Kluge said the number of killed Russian soldiers is higher than most estimates based on indirect data. He said the true figure is most likely close to half a million or above.
Russia recruits about 1,000 men each day, according to Kluge’s estimates. Official Russian recruitment data and targets suggest a figure of around 1,200 to 1,300 a day.
Kluge said it is not clear whether recruitment is enough to replace losses when wounded soldiers are factored in. He said there is a certain chance that it is not.
Recruitment tactics have become increasingly desperate, including criminal gangs getting involved. Kluge said this is not an urgent problem that will end the war, but it might force Russia to downsize the war or lower its intensity, with fewer attacks ongoing at the same time.
Recruitment is usually done at local or regional level, but there is a lot of pressure from Moscow on regions and districts to deliver enough men for the army.
Kluge said Russia’s poorer and more remote regions have suffered disproportionately, and that this is part of the answer to why the Russian dictator Vladimir Putin can tolerate the losses.
He said Russian society does not want to see the casualties and feels no solidarity with killed soldiers because they usually go to war for money. They sign up for huge sign on bonuses, and society says it is their own fault because they went there knowing what it was.
Kluge said this is not a threat to the regime as long as it remains the case. If the regime started to mobilise by force, that could be a different story.
Putin has tried to avoid another mass mobilisation and has been willing to spend considerable sums on sign on bonuses to find enough men willing to sign contracts. Kluge said Putin will try to delay forced mobilisation as much as possible because it is a political risk. When it happened in 2022, it led to huge lines at borders as men tried to leave the country.
Kluge said running out of soldiers is more likely to become Putin’s breaking point than running out of money. The money problem is a medium term issue and will not become critical next year or the year after. Budgetary situation has deteriorated, with higher deficits and less money for other parts of the budget.
Manpower is a much more sensitive issue, with fewer solutions available. A budget can be increased or taxes hiked, but mobilisation would be much less popular than a tax increase.
Kluge said the enormous losses could make Putin more willing to compromise once the war becomes so costly that it threatens his regime. He said the point where the cost and death toll make the war unfeasible to continue is the real problem for Putin.
The leaked data emerged as US mediated peace talks between Russia and Ukraine concluded in Abu Dhabi without a breakthrough on ending the war. The two sides agreed to a prisoner exchange, but fundamental disagreements remain.
Russia’s chief negotiator said the two sides exchanged views with the American side, finding common ground in some areas while remaining at odds in others. He said the dialogue will continue and that the world needs a new revived security system that would be fair and not discriminatory to any country.
Analysis and interviews were released by DW News, with Janis Kluge of the German Institute for International and Security Affairs in Berlin.
Be First to Comment